Technical note

Differential settlement on a buried pipeline: the beam model and a real case in PLE

A differential settlement does not move a pipe as a rigid body: it bends it, and by how much depends on how the settlement is described in the model. How PLE (ex Ple4Win) describes it on a buried pipeline, the formulas behind it and a real, anonymised case.

November 20266 min readGianludovico Spizuoco

When the ground under a pipeline settles unevenly, the pipe does not translate as a whole. It bends, passes part of the load to the soil through its supports and develops bending moments, shear and, if the deformation is large, axial tension. The shape of the settlement therefore matters at least as much as its amplitude. Here I explain how PLE (ex Ple4Win) describes it, which formulas follow and how I used it on a real, anonymised project.

Software
PLE (ex Ple4Win)
Load
Vertical ground subsidence, SUBSIDE table
Case data
Two settlements: 10 mm over a 44.7 m half wave (Double) and 5 mm over 8.8 m (Right), UNCF 1.5
References
NEN 3650-1 and NEN 3650-2

PLE and the SUBSIDE table

PLE (ex Ple4Win) is a pipe stress analysis program with a strong specialisation in pipelines and buried piping; according to the vendor it can model above-ground and buried sections in the same model. Vertical ground settlement is assigned in the SUBSIDE table, which does not impose a displacement at a node but a profile along the line, defined by four inputs:

  • SUBZMAX: maximum settlement in the z direction, negative downwards;
  • UNCF: uncertainty factor (≥ 1, default 1.5); SUBZMAX is always multiplied by UNCF;
  • LENGTH: length over which the settlement goes from zero to its maximum, equal to half a sine wavelength;
  • SINESHAPE: profile shape. Double is a half wave on both sides of the reference point X-P; Left and Right are a half wave on one side only, with zero settlement on the other; Block is a step from zero to SUBZMAX at X-P, constant over LENGTH.

In every sinusoidal case the maximum is at X-P.

The model: a beam on elastic soil

The affected length of pipe is described as a beam on distributed springs of stiffness k per unit length, whose lower ends follow the ground settlement s(x) (Winkler model):

EId4wdx4+k(w−s(x))=q(x)

where EI is the bending stiffness and q(x) the distributed load on the pipe (self-weight and contents). The characteristic length is 1/λ, with

λ=(k4EI)14

A sinusoidal profile of wavenumber ω is followed by the pipe only in part:

wmaxsmax=11+(ω2λ)4

For a half wave of length ℓ, ω = π/ℓ. If ℓ is large compared with 1/λ the pipe follows the ground; if it is small, the pipe bridges the settlement and its strains are lower than the ground's. In practice the springs have a limit (passive pressure, bearing capacity) and the problem is not linear: the formula is a guide, not a substitute for the calculation.

Pipe on elastic soil subjected to a ground settlementSchematic: ground settlement profile s(x), deflected pipe w(x) and distributed soil springs k between them.initial levelground settlement s(x)pipe w(x)soil springs kaSchematic, not to scale
Fig. 1 — Supported on springs, the pipe follows the ground settlement only in part. Schematic.

What the standard says

NEN 3650-1:2020, Annex C.4.1.2, treats the pipeline as a beam under differential settlement. The settlement load Qz is not transferred to the soil through moments or tangential stresses on the wall, but through the lateral support zones, where the reaction is limited by the bearing capacity; where the pipe does not follow the settlement, the reaction is limited by the passive pressure. The upper limit of the load is

Qz≤Qp+Qeg+Qfil

that is, passive pressure plus the weight of pipe and contents. The result is bending moments, shear and, depending on the deformation, axial tension from catenary action. For ring interaction (C.4.1.3) and for highly compressible soils, with heave and squeezing, refer to the standard.

Imposed displacement or sinusoidal profile

Imposing a displacement at a few nodes concentrates the rotation at those points, while the length between nodes stays straight. The PLE profile instead distributes the curvature along the half wave. With a = |SUBZMAX|·UNCF and ℓ = LENGTH, in the Double shape the settlement at distance s from X-P is

δ(s)=a2(1+cosπsℓ)

for |s| ≤ ℓ and zero elsewhere; in the Right and Left shapes the same expression applies on one side only. The maximum curvature and, for a pipe of outside diameter D that follows the ground completely (hence an upper bound), the bending strain are

κmax=a2(πℓ)2
ε=κD2=aπ2D4ℓ2

Curvature grows with 1/ℓ², while amplitude enters only linearly. In the Right and Left shapes there is also a displacement jump equal to a at X-P: it is not curvature but a differential that the pipe absorbs over a length set by the soil interaction, not by LENGTH. That is where the results deserve the closest reading.

Settlement shapes available in PLE and the curvature they produceTwo panels, SINESHAPE Double and Right: vertical settlement profile on top, curvature below.SINESHAPE = DoubleX-PaℓℓSINESHAPE = RightX-Paℓvertical settlement δ(s)curvature κ(s)jump a at X-P|κ|max = (a/2)(π/ℓ)²|κ|max = (a/2)(π/ℓ)²a = SUBZMAX·UNCF · ℓ = LENGTH · Schematic, not to scale
Fig. 2 — Double and Right shapes of the SUBSIDE table: settlement (top) and curvature (bottom). Schematic.

My experience on a project

On a project with a buried pipeline I applied the subsidence starting from the buried valve, towards the outside of the plant. In the SUBSIDE table (figure 3) I defined two settlements: sub1, SUBZMAX = −10 mm, LENGTH = 44.7 m, shape Double; sub2, SUBZMAX = −5 mm, LENGTH = 8.8 m, shape Right. With UNCF = 1.5 the applied settlements are 15 mm and 7.5 mm.

PLE SUBSIDE input table: sub1 with SUBZMAX −10 mm, LENGTH 44700 mm, Double; sub2 with SUBZMAX −5 mm, LENGTH 8800 mm, Right; UNCF 1.5
Fig. 3 — PLE SUBSIDE input table for the case described (SUBZMAX and LENGTH in mm).

The numbers say more than they seem to. Since LENGTH is half a wavelength, sub1 is a bowl 89.4 m long, with a maximum curvature of about 3.7·10−5 m−1 (radius of about 27 km). sub2 has half the amplitude but a length five times shorter: the curvature rises to about 4.8·10−4 m−1 (radius of about 2.1 km), 13 times that of sub1. In terms of curvature the small, short zone is the more severe one, and the jump at X-P typical of the Right shape comes on top.

Figure 4 shows the 3D visualisation of the S-LOAD table, column SETLZ*F (mm), along the route: the applied settlement can be read directly on the colour scale, with a maximum of the order of 15 mm, consistent with 10 mm × 1.5.

PLE 3D visualisation of the S-LOAD table, column SETLZ*F in mm: the buried route is coloured by the applied settlement, up to about 15 mm
Fig. 4 — PLE 3D visualisation of the S-LOAD table, SETLZ*F [mm]: settlement applied along the pipeline.

What I check in the model

  • I do not replace a distributed settlement with an imposed displacement at a few nodes.
  • I read LENGTH as half a wavelength: in Double the whole bowl is 2·LENGTH long.
  • I remember that SUBZMAX is multiplied by UNCF (default 1.5): the geotechnical value must not already be factored.
  • I compare ℓ with the characteristic length 1/λ before choosing the shape.
  • With Right or Left I read the results at the jump at X-P with particular care.
  • I keep the construction settlement fv and the settlement difference Δz separate (NEN 3650-2, Annex A).
  • I check that soil reactions stay within bearing capacity and passive pressure, and I check catenary tension in restrained sections.

Limits. The formulas describe the reference behaviour of the beam and of the sinusoidal half wave; the result depends on the soil interaction model and on the limits of the applied code, and must be read in the context of the individual project.

References

Need a stress analysis, a calculation package or a second opinion?

Send the line list, isometrics or model and the applicable code: you receive a defined scope and a fixed-price proposal.

Gianludovico Spizuoco
Talk directly to the engineerIng. Gianludovico Spizuoco · Registered professional engineer · stress analysis specialistYour request is read and answered by Gianludovico Spizuoco — the engineer who builds the model and signs the report. Quote within 48 working hours.